SURVEY OF POSSIBLY SUCCESSFUL PARTIAL TAKING CLAIMS
Partial taking claims have been upheld in cases involving development exactions, fees, or conditions where it is clear that private property is being “taken” by government and no cause-and-effect fairness nexus exists with respect to the exactions imposed.
Direct Taking of Property by Imposition of Development Exactions, Fees, or Conditions.
Partial taking claims have been upheld in cases involving development exactions, fees, or conditions where it is clear that private property is being “taken” by government and no cause-and-effect fairness nexus exists with respect to the exactions imposed. State courts, long before the Nollan and Dolan decisions of the Supreme Court, had applied this line of partial taking analysis to all manner of development exactions and conditions. This fairness nexus test max be applied by courts to development exactions involving land [1] money [2] public improvements [3] public facilities, [4] or public services [5] when imposed on an owner as a condition of development approval. This line of partial taking analysis expressly rejects the notion that owners wishing to develop land may be singled out to bear regulatory burdens for the purpose of addressing community problems that are not of their making and reflects the ruling in Nollan and Dolan that the police power may not be exercised by the extraction of unrelated or disproportionate benefits as a condition to development approval. [6]
Shifting of Burdens to Benefit Favored Persons or Groups
Partial taking claims have been upheld in cases involving regulatory burdens imposed on an owner’s use of land where the owner’s property is taken to provide a distinct benefit to another person or group (the legislatively designated beneficiaries) in order to remedy some perceived social problem or public need and no cause-and-effect fairness nexus exists between the owner who is burdened and the problem or need addressed by the regulation. [7] As stated in a recent court decision: “A proffered State interest, which by definition should serve and protect the general populace on a fairly and uniformly applied basis, should not be countenanced when, as occurs here, the statute instead benefits one special class for an essentially...