URBAN PLANNING AND THE TAKING OF PRIVATE PROPERTY IN THE UNITED STATES
The multifactored analysis set out in Penn Central has been widely criticized as the source of much mischief and confusion. Some later court decisions applied a similar form of analysis in a rather mechanical way interpreting Penn Central to require only that regulation not render land valueless.
The multifactored analysis set out in Penn Central has been widely criticized as the source of much mischief and confusion.27 Some later court decisions applied a similar form of analysis in a rather mechanical way interpreting Penn Central to require only that regulation not render land valueless.28 Under this view of regulatory takings, losses resulting from regulation, short of total destruction of land value, are held to be merely “disappointed expectations,” and potentially key criteria for assessing the basic fairness of uncompensated regulation are either casually dismissed or simply ignored.29 This interpretation of Penn Central actually provides no analysis at all of critical core issues related to the concept of horizontal equity underlying the Takings Clause. By eliminating considerations of fairness and justice in allocation of particular regulatory burdens, this type of Penn Central analysis fails to provide any coherent or principled basis for adjudging the permissible scope of uncompensated policy power regulation.
Penn Central’s utilitarian analysis has been largely superseeded by numerous Supreme Court and lower federal and state court regulatory taking decisions. More recent Supreme Court decisions repeatedly have rejected the notion that the Takings Clause only requires that land not be rendered valueless.30 Supreme Court decisions now make clear that common law ownership rights in land may be held to have been taken by regulation even short of total destruction in value or without regard to the extent of diminution in value.31 The primary focus in regulatory taking analysis may often not involve diminution in value at all but simply assessment of whether the regulation or permit decision is otherwise within the permissible scope of uncompensated police power regulation.32 As the Supreme Court reaffirmed in its recent Del Monte Dunes decision, the taking clause begins where the constitutional scope of uncompensated regulation ends.33
...