URBAN PLANNING AND THE TAKING OF PRIVATE PROPERTY IN THE UNITED STATES
Partial regulatory taking claims may include in the context of urban planning and zoning all taking claims that are not “categorical: or “per se” regulatory taking claims. When so defined, partial taking claims would not include the categorical taking claim that a regulation goes too far by compelling a property owner to suffer a physical invasion of his land or the categorical taking claim that a regulation goes too far by denying an owner all economically viable use of his land.
Introduction | The Supreme Court’s Recognition that the Takings Clause Limits the Permissible Scope of Uncompensated Regulation | The Supreme Court’s Analysis of Partial Regulatory Taking Claims
§ Introduction
Partial regulatory taking claims may include in the context of urban planning and zoning all taking claims that are not “categorical: or “per se” regulatory taking claims. When so defined, partial taking claims would not include the categorical taking claim that a regulation goes too far by compelling a property owner to suffer a physical invasion of his land [1] or the categorical taking claim that a regulation goes too far by denying an owner all economically viable use of his land. [2] Recent court decisions make clear that the crystallized lines of categorical taking analysis have not eliminated the Supreme Court’s ad hoc multifactored analysis of partial regulatory taking claims. [3] The concepts of fairness, causation, and proportionality which have in part shaped the lines of categorical taking analysis, are likely to continue to form the critical core analytical elements in the Supreme Court’s assessment of partial regulatory taking claims. [4] When analyzed in relation to the policy of horizontal equity reflected in the Takings Clause and in view of owner expectations as shaped by background principles of state property law, these three core concepts appear to provide a coherent and principled basis for limiting the constitutionally permissible scope of uncompensated police power regulation.
§ The Supreme Court’s Recognition that the Takings Clause Limits the Permissible Scope of Uncompensated Regulation
The Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that the Fifth Amendment Takings Clause imposes a constitutional limit on the permissible scope of uncompensated police power regulation. This recognition by the Court both reflects and promotes the historical interplay between this country’s common law property rights tradition, [5] the exercise of government police power, [6] and the role of the courts in our constitutional system of protecting individual rights, including private property rights. [7]...